Heel Sheamus or babyface Sheamus?

Definitely face. Aside from the fact that I prefer the character, I personally find his promos etc to be better as a face because that is Sheamus O'Shaunessy all over. All the Irish shtick, all the "what's the craic". That's not a gimmick. That IS Sheamus, and I generally prefer when a wrestler puts elements of their own personality into their gimmicks, rather than it being all character.

I just see him better as a heel. He has the look and the attitude that feels better as a heel.

The size, mustache and beard, and just general presence makes me like him better as a heel.
I see him more as a pissed off Irishman than a jovial cocky-mouthed Irishman.

I love him as face, but not making jokes, I wanted to be the face that came out and said "i'll fight 'em" to Henry

Face. I enjoyed him as a heel... but then I was just so into his babyface turn. It just felt so right. I could never have even envisioned him as babyface until he turned... and it was amazing.

Big Red Machine wrote:Face. I enjoyed him as a heel... but then I was just so into his babyface turn. It just felt so right. I could never have even envisioned him as babyface until he turned... and it was amazing.

This, a million times.

Face.

To me he was a life long heel, no way he could ever turn face. He just didn't have the look or demeanour. But he actually looks more comfortable, and it shows. He'd be perfect to counteract Mark Henry, because hes a face that's not to be fucked with & with Henry at the best of his career, this'd be perfect to push Sheamus to the heights he was with Triple H.

I prefer him as a face as well but not the joke cracking type, but the i'll step up and fight this guy thing he did with Mark Henry which could have been great if they kept it up. I thought he'd be the one to curb Henry's mean streak a bit but he was just another victim.

Rabid619 wrote:I prefer him as a face as well but not the joke cracking type, but the i'll step up and fight this guy thing he did with Mark Henry which could have been great if they kept it up. I thought he'd be the one to curb Henry's mean streak a bit but he was just another victim.

I wanna believe that since he was one guy that wasn't taken out completely, he'll come back and challenge for the title after Henry destroys Orton in the HIAC.

cero2k wrote:I wanna believe that since he was one guy that wasn't taken out completely, he'll come back and challenge for the title after Henry destroys Orton in the HIAC.

I'd be alright with that. Orton is the face of SmackDown but he doesn't ALWAYS need to be in a feud with the title on the line.

cero2k wrote:

Rabid619 wrote:I prefer him as a face as well but not the joke cracking type, but the i'll step up and fight this guy thing he did with Mark Henry which could have been great if they kept it up. I thought he'd be the one to curb Henry's mean streak a bit but he was just another victim.

I wanna believe that since he was one guy that wasn't taken out completely, he'll come back and challenge for the title after Henry destroys Orton in the HIAC.

Yeah. They are definitely doing Sheamus vs. Christian for #1 contendership at HIAC and after Orton loses, it will be Sheamus vs. Henry at Survivor Series.

Big Red Machine wrote:

cero2k wrote:

Rabid619 wrote:I prefer him as a face as well but not the joke cracking type, but the i'll step up and fight this guy thing he did with Mark Henry which could have been great if they kept it up. I thought he'd be the one to curb Henry's mean streak a bit but he was just another victim.

I wanna believe that since he was one guy that wasn't taken out completely, he'll come back and challenge for the title after Henry destroys Orton in the HIAC.

Yeah. They are definitely doing Sheamus vs. Christian for #1 contendership at HIAC and after Orton loses, it will be Sheamus vs. Henry at Survivor Series.

Can't wait for Sheamus vs christian, i say it'd be a great match.

Look out for an Orton/Sheamus vs Christian/Henry tag match inbetween.

I actually liked him as a heel. I just prefer heels over faces to put it simply

Big Red Machine wrote: Yeah. They are definitely doing Sheamus vs. Christian for #1 contendership at HIAC and after Orton loses, it will be Sheamus vs. Henry at Survivor Series.

wouldn't it be awesome for smackdown to make an SS team to take on Henry, and yet Henry wins. oh the glory of a real monster wrestler

e-moose wrote:Heel Sheamus wasn't terribly exciting. He's playing a face much better. Perhaps now that he has more WWE experience, he may surprise us and play a much better heel than before.

This

i prefer heel sheamus, but i think he plays a face soo much better