Roderick Strong and Kyle O'Reilly represented The Undisputed Era.

Eric Young and Killian Dain represented Sanity. Fish and O'Reilly won the match and were originally champions as a duo, but after Fish suffered a torn ACL and torn MCL in his left knee, he was replaced by Adam Cole who, at NXT TakeOver: New Orleans on April 7, 2018 was considered champion with Fish and O'Reilly under the Freebird Rule, with WWE crediting him as "the first ever double champion in NXT history" after he won the NXT North American Championship in the same night. However, on the April 11 tapings of NXT, Strong became recognized as champion in Cole's place, with Cole's reign becoming retroactively unrecognized. WWE recognizes this as a single uninterrupted reign for Fish, O'Reilly, and Strong that began on December 20, 2017, when Fish and O'Reilly's title win episode aired on tape delay.

Wolfe and Young won the match, but Dain was also recognized as champion under the Freebird Rule.

This was a two-out-of-three falls match.

Defeated British Ambition's Adrian Neville and Bo Dallas (who filled in for the injured Oliver Grey).

Defeated The Wyatt Family in the NXT Tag Team Title Tournament to become the first champions.