cero2k wrote: ↑Apr 22nd, '20, 13:19
Big Red Machine wrote: ↑Apr 21st, '20, 13:52
1. I don't think they're flying production people in. I think they're using locals in Florida who happen to work for WWE already (and I'd guess that at this point a good chunk of their production people either live near the PC or Stamford).
2. It's not "paranoia to lose money." It's paranoia to lose one's livelihood. That's what Vince thinks could happen to him. Do I think that's unfounded? Yes. But as I pointed out above, this sort of thing does not fit Vince's usual pattern of treating talent. I think he's scared sh*tless and thus acting irrationally. You might not want to admit it because he's rich and because he's the evil Vince McMahon who killed wrestling, but Vince is a human being, too, and thus he deserves everyone making some attempt at sympathizing with him and trying to understand his feelings just as much as everyone else in the world does.
3. For all we know, Vince switched back to tapings rather than going live because the networks told him not to worry about it. In fact, that seems like the most logical thing to me.
4. You know... I don't seem to recall you bringing up how asking people to come to travel and come to work was a moral evil because it was endangering them and their families when AEW was running tapings. I will now accept your rant on what evil, greedy corporate assholes Cody, Tony, Kenny, Brandi, and the Bucks are.
5. If I remember correctly, WWE (and AEW, for that matter) had a policy in place where no one had to come to work if they didn't want to, and people wold not be punished for not coming to work (and no, these releases clearly aren't punishment for not working because a bunch of the people who got laid off
were working the shows.
6. I think that them making good enough money that they'll be okay for a few months is a reason that this isn't the moral evil you're trying to portray it as. These are not shift-workers at restaurants.
7. Trust me. I wish they'd fire Ronda and Brock. Firing Roman would open them up to a lawsuit because they already told people that we won't punish you if you don't feel safe coming to work, and that is exactly why Roman pulled out.
8. Even in circumstances like this, business strategy still applies. That's just being a responsible business owner. If AEW gets to point where they have to let people go, you can be sure that Butcher & Blade and Private Party will be gone long before Lucha Bros, and you wouldn't bat an eyelash at it. They're going to keep their top names and that's a perfectly reasonable thing to do, and you know it.
9. You're right about the NXT people and the and the producers and the referees. And like I said before, it sucks and I wish it didn't happen. They shouldn't have let them go, but they apparently felt they needed to. But by the same argument, the NXT people probably aren't going to affect the bottom line anywhere near as much as a few main roster cuts would.
10. For Chioda and Silfies in particular... do you think Vince WANTED to get rid of people who have been with him for over thirty years? They were probably the referee and non-Kevin Dunn production person who were making the most.
2. Lol, a 74 yr-old billionaire worried about livelihood. Get out of here. I nominate that for post of the year. He should be worried about getting sick instead.
4. You're missing the point, the problem is not doing tapings, i'm not advocating to 100% stop wrestling. I'm saying do it in a way that benefits and protects your staff and talent as the priority, and not the company's profit margins. I don't have to blame AEW because they're not doing shows every week for the benefit of the company, they taped a ton of episodes so people have time to go home, quarantine, and get to see their families. Impact taped more than usual.
If we're gonna bring up AEW, let's compare the culture we're seeing. (5) Yeah, all companies are pretty much 'come if you want', but look at who has their champions on TV? Mox isn't there. Tessa and The North cancelled their Rebellion matches. Rush and Naito are not even sweating it. WWE has both Galloway and Strowman there, and the latter is a prime example that they change pushes and booking because they want the champion to be there. AEW has JR home, Impact has Callis home, WWE has Lawler there in person. The culture between these promotions is visibly different.
(1) they're surely not traveling, but they are going to work weekly to a job that is 1000% not essential, being there WITH people who are traveling and people who are touching each other as part of the job.
6. And the WWE is not a mom and pop shop either. WWE is far better prepared to 'be ok' through this, than the fired employees. You say that Vince is worried about his livelihood, well, he fucked over a lot of people's livelihoods for that, because he's full of greed and egoism and we know that he'll step over everyone all the time. Who is to say that the industry won't be hurt enough at the end and some of these people will not find jobs? it's not like AEW is just going to hire everyone. WWE fired people when they knew other promotions wouldn't be able to pick them up.
7. Oh no, that doesn't matter. They're all cost reducing reasons, it's not because he didn't want to come to work. Hell, it's a furlough!, he's coming back when it's all settle. He'll be ok.
8. But it hasn't happened, it hasn't happened in one single major promotion in the world, except the Fed. If you want to use other promotions as the excuse that it's all business, then you're gonna have to wait for another major promotion to do it. Up until now, WWE is shit.
10. Maybe, employees with long history tend to earn a lot more than those doing the same thing that were just hired, and we know Vince is not hyped about 'old' people. In Vince's deranged mind, he probably thinks that he's helping them stay home by firing them
2. He probably is worried about getting sick. And my whole point is that the man doesn't seem to be very mentally well. I think it's entirely possible that his mindset is "oh my G-d I just lost a whole bunch of money the XFL and now I need to do whatever it takes to ensure that I don't lose WWE, too, because without WWE, I don't have anything."
4. And WWE is taping in bunches, now, too. Doing tapings in way that AEW did is hard on the workers(both wrestling and production), as TNA learned. I don't see much wrong with WWE asking employees to drive in their cars to a building a few times a month. WWE employees should be using the same common sense rules that apply to employees of any other business that is currently open ("if you don't feel well or think you might have been exposed, STAY HOME!" etc.). WWE isn't asking people to fly across the country (and they should be discouraging people from doing so).
5.A. Mox was at the tapings (unless he and Swagger wrestled in a totally different building)
5.B. The Strowman change was about more than that. Firstly, they weren't going to keep the belt on Goldberg either way because Goldberg wasn't going to wrestle much. Secondly, they couldn't deliver advertised match, so they delivered a match with a finish they thought fans would like. "If you need to make a substitution you have the babyface go over" is a very old rule of booking to make the fans happy even though they didn't get to see the advertised match. They're not punishing Roman for staying home. They'll put the belt right back on him at the first big PPV after things open up again.
5.C. When it comes to WWE having a lot more people show up than over promotions, you're forgetting the two following important points:
- A huge chunk of the roster lives in the Orlando area anyway.
- A bunch of them probably wanted to make sure they were able to be there for Mania anyway and just decided not to go home (a bunch of the are living on friends couches because hotel rooms are already all booked up).
I agree that Lawler shouldn't be there, but he is. Hell, I don't think any company should have more than one announcer around (although, again, WWE has a lot more of them withing driving distance). And you're forgetting that WWE DOES have some announcers home (Mauro, Nigel).
6. I agree that WWE is probably more likely to come out of this fine than AEW due to money they have in reserve, but WWE also has expenses that are far greater than AEW's. As Thelone noted, they had OVER TWO HUNDRED wrestlers under contract, and that's just wrestlers. They've also got more production staff, NXT trainers, people on legends deals, etc.
Most other promotions might not be able to pick these people up right now... although AEW absolute could make offers right now if they wanted to. They have the money to do so, but it's not necessarily a smart move to start paying when you don't know how long you'll actually be able to use them for because they might not be able to start for six months. But even if AEW doesn't make any offers right now, that doesn't change the fact that these people will be free agents in a little over 90 days (actually they're all free agents now, but can't appear anywhere until the 90 days are up. There is no reason they can't sign with someone and shoot promos to be released at a later date), and when things do open up again, there is going to be a lot of competition for the ones people want, and WWE will have to pay a lot more to get these guys than they were making when they were released.
For the Tino Sabbattellis of the world there wouldn't be a bidding war for them under normal circumstances, either.
7. I guess McDevitt didn't feel confident making that argument in front of a jury. Also, I think we both know that WWE wants Brock and Ronda at least nominally under contract for the next few years just because they will help with the next round of Fox and USA negotiations.
8. No, I don't have to wait for that to happen, because we all know it's true. Lucha Bros are worth more than Private Party and Blutcher & Blade combined, so if AEW were ever in financial straits, they'd keep them on at the cost of the other four. It's how every promotion ever has operated. ROH early on would rather not bring in four JAPW flippy guys than not pay for Dragon's plane ticket, TNA let numerous interchangable X-Division guys go before they told James Storm they couldn't pay him what he wanted, and WCW released all of the Nitro Girls and most of the Cruiserweights but never even tried to cut Sting (or, if you prefer, there was a reason Rey was kept under contract when most of the other luchadors were let go).